Yankees vs Mets Prediction 13 September 2026
📡 After falling 4-6, the Mets responded in emphatic fashion-routing the Yankees 12-2 to even up the series. Zack Thornton went seven strong innings, while the offense looked every bit as explosive as it did in Miami, where they racked up 31 runs over three games. The Subway Series finale will see Cam Schlittler go head-to-head with Christian Scott.
Head-to-Head
📊 The Mets have now taken six of the last ten head-to-head matchups. More importantly for this particular line, they've scored at least four runs in seven of those games. In the current series, the visitors have put up four and 12 runs respectively.
Head-to-head statistics Yankees - Mets

New York Yankees Team Overview
The Yankees remain one of the American League’s powerhouses, but Saturday saw them suffer a rare complete collapse. Gerrit Cole couldn’t contain the Mets, while the offense managed just two runs. Tonight, the hosts turn to their top pitcher by season ERA, making the challenge much tougher for the Mets.
Match Results: New York Yankees

New York Mets Team Overview
The Mets are enjoying one of their strongest offensive stretches of the season. Over their last five games, they’ve racked up 47 runs: 9, 7, 15, 4, and 12. Francisco Lindor, Juan Soto, and the depth in the heart of the order are putting constant pressure on opposing pitchers, regardless of the quality of the starter on the mound.
Match Results: New York Mets
⚾ Starting Pitchers
Cam Schlittler gets the nod for the Yankees-he’s 13-6 with a 2.01 ERA and 220 strikeouts. That’s the main argument against betting against New York: he’s putting together a season worthy of the league’s elite starters and rarely gives up big innings.
Christian Scott takes the mound for the Mets-he’s 4-4 with a 3.81 ERA and 120 strikeouts. His job will be to keep the game within reach, making sure the visitors’ offense doesn’t have to chase an early deficit.
⭐ Editor’s Prediction
Schlittler poses a significant challenge on the mound, but the Mets’ line is set at just four runs for the entire game. New York have scored at least four in each of their last five outings, racking up a total of 47 runs during that stretch. In seven of the last ten Subway Series matchups, the Mets have also managed to reach the four-run mark. Even if Schlittler delivers a strong six innings, the Mets’ current offensive form should allow them to capitalize against the bullpen. Our pick: New York Mets Team Total Over 3.5.