Yankees vs Mets Prediction 11 September 2026
📡 The Subway Series is carrying a September significance it hasn't seen in years. The Yankees have just swept Colorado, capping the series with a commanding 10-3 win to climb to 84-62. The Mets arrive fresh off a wild 15-14 victory in Miami and riding a four-game winning streak. For the Yankees, it's especially promising that their offense is firing on all cylinders heading into the derby: they've racked up 21 runs over their last three games and are averaging 5.1 runs across their past ten outings.
Head-to-Head
📊 The Mets have taken six of the last ten head-to-head matchups, while the Yankees have claimed four. There’s no clear-cut dominance in this rivalry: both teams frequently trade momentum from series to series. However, the current context sets this showdown apart from previous meetings - the Yankees are playing at home and come into this game after three straight outings where they’ve scored at least five runs.
Head-to-head statistics Yankees - Mets

New York Yankees Team Overview
The Yankees have won seven of their last ten games, narrowing the gap to Tampa Bay to just three wins. Anthony Volpe returned to the lineup with a three-hit performance and a grand slam, capping off the previous night with five RBIs. With Luis Garcia, Spencer Jones, Cody Bellinger, and a deep bottom of the order, New York continue to apply pressure even when their top hitters don't deliver early. Over their last ten games, the Yankees have racked up 51 runs.
Match Results: New York Yankees

New York Mets Team Overview
The Mets have found another gear since the trade deadline, stringing together four consecutive wins. Their most recent outing perfectly illustrates the team’s current form: New York jumped out to an 8-0 lead, allowed Miami to claw all the way back, but then responded with a six-run burst to secure a wild 15-14 victory. This lineup is dangerous, but conceding 14 runs also exposed just how vulnerable the pitching staff can be when the starters’ game plan unravels.
Match Results: New York Mets
⚾ Starting Pitchers
Nolan McLean gets the nod for the Mets-he’s 11-8 this season with a 3.06 ERA, a 1.14 WHIP, and 179 strikeouts. McLean is enjoying a strong campaign and will pose a real challenge for the home side. That said, even a reliable arm like McLean rarely goes the distance, and the Yankees have recently excelled at punishing opposing pitchers once they cycle through the order.
As of writing, MLB has yet to officially confirm the Yankees’ starting pitcher. While this doesn’t impact the assessment of their offense, it’s too early to assign a specific starter or include his stats in this preview.
⭐ Editor’s Prediction
McLean gives the Mets a solid start, so the Yankees don’t necessarily need to explode for a big first or second inning. For this line, four runs from the hosts will be enough-and right now, they’re averaging 5.1 runs per game over their last 10, fresh off a 10-run outburst. Volpe’s return has added real punch to the lineup, making it deeper and more dangerous, while Yankee Stadium amplifies the value of any well-struck ball. Even if McLean gets off to a strong start, the Yankees will still have several innings against the Mets’ bullpen. We’re backing the New York Yankees’ individual total over 3.5 runs.