Brewers vs Reds Prediction 11 September 2026
📡 Cincinnati probably weren't eager to face the division leaders right after their trip to Los Angeles. The Reds were swept by the Dodgers in three games, capped off by a 1-14 blowout in the finale. Yet just a week ago, it was Milwaukee who brought out a very different side of this offense: Cincinnati put up 7, 5, and 12 runs in that series. The Brewers, meanwhile, have just completed a sweep of the Cubs and return home with a 91-56 record. The opener features Andrew Abbott and Shane Drohan-neither of whom boasts a dominant season ERA.
Head-to-Head
📊 Milwaukee have claimed victory in 7 of the last 10 head-to-head clashes, while Cincinnati have won three. Notably, the three most recent meetings have been high-scoring affairs: 10-7, 3-5, and 8-12. Each of those games saw the total runs surpass the 7.5 mark, with both teams combining for 45 runs across the series.
Head-to-head statistics Brewers - Reds

Milwaukee Brewers Team Overview
The Brewers are enjoying their best season in MLB and have just swept the Cubs in a three-game series. In the series finale, Milwaukee’s offense erupted for eight runs, sealing the sweep with an 8-6 victory. Jackson Chourio, Christian Yelich, and the depth in the heart of the order continue to fuel the Brewers’ scoring, even when they start slowly. Milwaukee are especially dangerous after the fifth inning, when opponents are forced to move from their starting pitcher to more vulnerable bullpen arms.
Match Results: Milwaukee Brewers

Cincinnati Reds Team Overview
The Reds have dropped seven straight and, following their series in Los Angeles, now sit at 69-77. Still, Elly De La Cruz has homered in five consecutive games, remaining a constant threat regardless of the team’s overall struggles. Just a week ago against Milwaukee, Cincinnati put up 24 runs in two wins and managed seven even in defeat. This particular Brewers pitching staff has already served up far more hittable pitches to the Reds than the Dodgers did.
Match Results: Cincinnati Reds
⚾ Starting Pitchers
Shane Drohan gets the nod for Milwaukee-he’s 7-5 with a 4.09 ERA and 115 strikeouts. He’s having a solid, workmanlike season, but he’s not the kind of pitcher who routinely shuts opponents out or limits them to just a single run.
Andrew Abbott takes the mound for Cincinnati-he’s 6-10 with a 4.43 ERA and 120 strikeouts. Just a week ago, he faced Milwaukee, allowing two runs (one earned) over four innings before a weather delay cut his outing short. Now he faces one of the league’s deepest lineups again, this time on their home turf.
⭐ Editor’s Prediction
Cincinnati arrive on the back of a tough sweep, but that doesn't overshadow their recent scoring history against Milwaukee. Just a week ago, these clubs combined for at least eight runs in three straight games-17, 8, and 20 runs, respectively. Tonight, Drouin (ERA 4.09) and Abbott (ERA 4.43) get the starting nods, meaning neither side holds a clear advantage on the mound. The Brewers are more than capable of putting up five or six runs themselves, and a couple of power plays from De La Cruz and company could quickly push the total past the threshold. We're backing the over 7.5 total runs in this one.