Сincinnati vs Columbus Crew Prediction 27 October 2025
🔊 MLS Playoffs are here, and fans have been eagerly awaiting their start. It won't be long before we know who will lift the trophy this season. But let's take it step by step: let's dive into the matchup between Cincinnati and Columbus Crew. While both teams had varied performances in the regular season, they are fairly evenly matched in terms of strength. So, who has the edge? Let's try to figure it out. Our editorial team offers their prediction for this encounter.
Head-to-Head
📊 The teams have faced each other twice this season. Columbus secured a win in one match and drew the other. Over a longer stretch, the Crew also hold the advantage. We're in for an exciting rivalry.
Head-to-head statistics Сincinnati - Columbus Crew

Cincinnati Team Overview
🔵 The team finished second in the conference, trailing slightly behind Philadelphia and edging out Inter Miami on tiebreakers. Cincinnati's performances are a mixed bag; they can deliver a spectacular match one day and then fall apart the next. A significant concern is that Columbus are their toughest possible opponents, and historically, things haven't gone well against them.
⚪️ Cincinnati are unbeaten in their last five matches, but that might not mean much. Many teams were winding down the regular season with little motivation. Cincinnati played their usual balanced style, picking up relatively easy points. Notably, their leader Evander is in good form, having scored even in the final match of the regular season. However, this highlights another issue: the team relies heavily on the Brazilian, with no other standout players in the squad.
Match Results: Cincinnati

Columbus Crew Team Overview
⚫️ Crew have finally clinched a playoff spot, despite their recent poor form. With only three wins in their last ten matches and three losses against non-top opponents, they find themselves in 7th place in the conference, teetering on the edge of the wild-card games. However, the draw favors Columbus, as they boast an excellent head-to-head record against Cincinnati. This matchup promises to be intriguing.
⚪️ The team secured a crucial win in their final regular season game, which was decisive in determining the standings. They earned a hard-fought victory over New York Red Bulls (3-1). Columbus quickly recovered after conceding an early goal and consistently pressured their opponents. This resilience is a notable strength: the players can rally during critical moments, though they still lack consistency.
Match Results: Columbus Crew
Latest news
Cincinnati
⚠️ Injuries are a concern, but it's tough to predict how they'll impact the result. Defenders Miazga, Engel, and Smith are sidelined. The first two have seen significant playing time. Additionally, rotation forward Luca Orellano will also miss out.
Columbus Crew
⚠️ The big question is whether Diego Rossi will participate in the match. The club's top scorer is currently sidelined with an injury. His fitness remains uncertain. It's a crucial factor.
Prediction for the 1st half
Head-to-Head Matches:
- Total encounters - 19;
- First-half wins at home for hosts - 4; for visitors away - 1; number of draws - 5;
- Average first-half total: 1.63;
- Today's home team scores on average 0.74, while the visitors net 0.89.
First-Half Stats: Cincinnati (home) vs Columbus Crew (away)
- matches played in the tournament: 17 vs 17;
- wins: 6 (35.29%) vs 3 (17.65%);
- losses: 1 (5.88%) vs 6 (35.29%);
- draws: 10 (58.82%) vs 8 (47.06%);
- Average goals scored: 0.82 vs 1.94;
- Average goals conceded: 0.24 vs 1.06.
Last 10 Matches (Overall):
- wins: 4 vs 3;
- losses: 1 vs 2;
- draws: 5 vs 5;
- Average first-half total: 1 (scored - 0.7, conceded - 0.3) vs 1.7 (scored - 1, conceded - 0.7).
- Cincinnati scored in the 1st half in 6 of last 7 home games against Columbus Crew (MLS).
- Columbus Crew conceded in the 1st half in 13 of last 15 away games (MLS).
Prediction on the outcome
H2H:
- number of encounters - 19;
- home team wins - 4, away team wins - 9, draws - 6.
Statistics: Cincinnati vs Columbus Crew
- matches played in the tournament: 34 vs 34;
- wins: 20 vs 14;
- win percentage: 59% vs 41%;
- losses: 9 vs 8;
- draws: 5 vs 12.
Last 10 matches:
- wins: 5 vs 3;
- losses: 4 vs 3;
- draws: 1 vs 4.
- Columbus Crew have not won in 7 of last 8 away games.
Prediction on the over/under
H2H
- today's home team scores on average - 1.16, the guests - 2.05;
- average Over/Under goals in H2H matches - 3.21;
- both teams scored: overall - 11; at the home team's field - 7.
Statistics: Cincinnati vs Columbus Crew
- average total in the tournament: 2.71 vs 3.12;
- average total goals scored: 1.53 vs 1.62;
- average total in the 1st half: 0.74 vs 0.94;
- average total in the 2nd half: 0.79 vs 0.68;
- Cincinnati: average total at home in the tournament - 1.59;
- Columbus Crew: average total away in the tournament - 1.53;
- last 10 matches (average total): 1.4 (home - 1) vs 1.5 (away - 1.5).
- Over 2.5 goals scored in 6 of last 7 Cincinnati home games against Columbus Crew (MLS).
Prediction on corners
Cincinnati: Statistics
- season: average Over/Under in the tournament - 4.21; at home field - 4.53;
- last 10 matches: average Over/Under - 4; at home field - 4.57.
Columbus Crew: Statistics
- season: average Over/Under in the tournament - 4.97, away - 4.12;
- last 10 matches: average Over/Under - 4; away - 4.67.
- Under 9.5 corners in last 6 Cincinnati home games against Columbus Crew (MLS).
Prediction on cards
H2H
- average Over/Under yellow cards in H2H matches - 4.64 (2.32 for home team and 2.32 for away team);
- average Over/Under yellow cards at the home team's field - 4.8 (2.7 for home team and 2.1 for away team).
Cincinnati: Statistics
- season: average Over/Under in the tournament - 1.97; at home - 2.12;
- last 10 matches: average Over/Under - 1.7; at home - 2.
Columbus Crew: Statistics
- season: average Over/Under in the tournament - 1.29, away - 1.47;
- last 10 matches: average Over/Under - 1.2; away - 1.17.
Prediction on BTTS
H2H:
- number of encounters - 19;
- both teams scored all-time - 11 times;
- on the home team’s field - 7 times.
Statistics: Cincinnati vs Columbus Crew
- number of matches played in the tournament: 34 vs 34;
- number of matches in the season where both teams scored (BTTS): 18 vs 26;
- number of BTTS matches for Cincinnati at home - 9 (53%);
- number of BTTS matches for Columbus Crew away - 13 (76%).
Last 10 matches:
- number of BTTS matches: 5 vs 7;
- BTTS matches for Cincinnati at home - 3 (43%);
- BTTS matches for Columbus Crew away - 4 (67%).
- Cincinnati have scored and conceded in 6 of last 7 home games against Columbus Crew (MLS).
Editorial Prediction
The hosts are likely to tighten up and play defensively, and this match might be the perfect occasion for such a strategy. Columbus are not the easiest opponents, so it's crucial to stay focused throughout the game. Meanwhile, the visitors find themselves in a precarious position; with Rossi in the lineup, they are a completely different team compared to when he's absent. It seems Columbus might be limited in their attacking options here. We suggest betting on under 3.5 goals, which aligns well with the initial data and has hit in Cincinnati's last seven home games consecutively. As for the scoreline, it could very well end up being a 2-1 victory for Cincinnati.