Columbus vs New York Rangers Prediction 17 October 2026
🔊 Conceding seven goals in a single game is a tough pill to swallow. When both upcoming opponents suffer this fate, questions about their defensive setups only intensify. Columbus struggled on home ice against Florida, allowing the Panthers to capitalize on the power play four times. Meanwhile, the Rangers faced similar troubles in New Jersey, despite having won six of their previous eight outings. Now, both teams will look to bounce back in this head-to-head clash. Notably, it was the Blue Jackets who found more ways to beat the New Yorkers last season.
Five points out of a possible six
📊 Last season, Columbus took two out of three games against the Rangers. However, one of those wins came in overtime, while New York’s lone victory was decided in a shootout. That means the Blue Jackets claimed five out of a possible six points, with the Rangers picking up three. The March clash proved especially high-scoring, as Columbus secured a 6-3 win behind a brace from Adam Fantilli. That matchup remains the most recent head-to-head meeting between these teams.
Head-to-head statistics Columbus - New York Rangers
The second period turns into a disaster.
Columbus got off to a promising start this season, picking up two wins from their first three games. However, Rick Bowness’s side then suffered back-to-back defeats, conceding a total of 12 goals. The Blue Jackets first fell to St. Louis (3-5), then shipped seven against Florida. What’s especially concerning is how easily opponents are capitalizing on their chances. Columbus allow goals on 16.6% of shots on target-the second-worst rate in the league, ahead of only Calgary. The second period has been a particular problem: they’re conceding an average of two goals per middle frame, the highest mark in the NHL. On top of that, injuries have hit hard, with Dante Fabbro, Isac Lundeström, and Vladislav Provorov all sidelined.
Against Florida, things actually started well. Kent Johnson opened the scoring in the first period, but Columbus’s game unraveled after the break. Brady Tkachuk recorded a natural hat trick in just over eight minutes-twice on the power play. Carter Verhaeghe then converted another Columbus penalty, and early in the third Sam Reinhart made it 5-1. In the end, the Panthers cruised to a 7-3 win, scoring on four of their six power-play opportunities. Cam Talbot gave up six goals on 23 shots before being replaced by Jet Greaves. Bowness didn’t hide his frustration postgame, openly criticizing the self-inflicted mistakes his team keeps making. If the penalties continue at this rate, Columbus could face more of the same problems against the Rangers.
Match Results: Columbus Blue Jackets
Seven goals after a strong start
The Rangers have opened the regular season with far more confidence than their upcoming opponents. Six wins in eight games have seen Mike Sullivan’s side cement their place among the Eastern Conference frontrunners. Offensively, there’s no shortage of players ready to take charge: New York are converting 13.7% of their shots on goal, ranking eighth league-wide. However, their latest outing against New Jersey exposed just how costly Igor Shesterkin’s absence can be. The Russian goaltender is sidelined through injury, as are Joonas Korpisalo, Adam Sýkora, and Joe Veleno. As a result, the Rangers’ goaltending depth is under serious strain heading into the trip to Columbus.
In New Jersey, the team suffered a heavy 1-7 defeat. Both goalies stepping in for Shesterkin struggled to cope with the Devils’ relentless attack, and the Rangers’ lone goal came on the power play from Pavel Dorofeyev, assisted by Alexis Lafrenière and Adam Fox. Lafrenière has now extended his points streak to six games, tallying 11 points and seven goals in that stretch. Fox, meanwhile, pushed his assist streak to three games, bringing his total to nine and moving him to the top of the NHL’s defensemen leaderboard. Interestingly, even in a blowout loss, the Rangers’ penalty kill remained flawless-they neutralized all four shorthanded situations. Over the season, New York have killed off 26 of 28 penalties, boasting a 92.9% success rate. So despite the rout in New Jersey, it’s clear that not everything is falling apart for the Rangers.
Match Results: New York Rangers
Prediction for the 1st period
On the road, the Rangers rarely engage in high-scoring shootouts right from the opening faceoff. In their last five away games, New York and their opponents have never combined for more than one goal in the first period. Even after conceding seven goals against New Jersey, there’s little reason to expect a similar scenario to unfold early in their next outing. Columbus, meanwhile, tend to give up the bulk of their goals in the second period rather than the first. The pick here is under 1.5 goals in the first period.
Total Prediction
Columbus are struggling defensively right now, but their own scoring output remains modest. In 15 of their last 17 games, the Blue Jackets have managed no more than three goals. That trend holds at home as well, with nine out of ten recent outings seeing them score three or fewer, and six of their past seven games following suit. Even in their last two defeats-where opponents combined for 12 goals-Columbus could only respond with three goals per game. The Rangers are also coming off a heavy loss, but their penalty kill remains among the league’s best. The pick here is Columbus under 3.5 team total goals.
Match Outcome Prediction
Columbus have struggled to deliver home wins lately, failing to secure victory in regulation time in nine of their last ten games at Nationwide Arena. The Blue Jackets are coming off back-to-back defeats and continue to struggle defensively, conceding far too many goals. The Rangers, meanwhile, are also looking to bounce back after a disappointing result against New Jersey, but with six wins from their opening eight games, they have shown plenty of resilience. However, last season’s head-to-head meetings suggest the visitors are far from guaranteed winners. The pick: New York Rangers Double Chance (X2) in Regulation.
⭐️ Editor’s Prediction
Seven goals from Florida and just as many from New Jersey-those results make the total goals market worth a closer look. Columbus have conceded 12 goals across their last two outings, including four power-play goals surrendered against the Panthers. The Rangers also endured a tough night recently, but their attack boasts enough firepower to capitalize on any defensive lapses. The numbers back it up: the over 5.5 goals line has landed in each of Columbus’ last two games and in two of the Rangers’ previous three. Last season, these teams also cleared this mark twice in their head-to-head meetings. While New York may consider a more cautious approach after their recent blowout, the current defensive form of both sides suggests we should expect at least six goals. My pick: over 5.5 total goals.
Will this prediction come true?
No comments
Betting Tips: Columbus Blue Jackets - New York Rangers
in 6 of last 7 games (NHL).
in 9 of last 10 home games (NHL).in 6 of last 7 home games (NHL).in last 9 games (NHL).Other predictions
