Edmonton vs New York Islanders Prediction 16 January 2026
📣 The Islanders continue their Canadian tour, and this time Patrick Roy's squad faces the Stanley Cup runners-up, Edmonton. Can the New Yorkers extend their successful run against the Oilers? We'll find out soon enough.
Head-to-Head
Last season, the teams faced off twice, and interestingly, both encounters went beyond regulation time. In mid-November, the Canadian side triumphed in overtime with a 4-3 victory. Edmonton's Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl dazzled as usual, while New York's seasoned Anders Lee scored twice late in the third period. In March, the Islanders sought revenge against Draisaitl and company, but it wasn't to be. The unstoppable German netted two more goals, one again in overtime. This season, the New Yorkers and the Albertans have already clashed at UBS Arena. The hosts secured a 4-2 win, with Bo Horvat, returning after missing several games, scoring a hat-trick.
Head-to-head statistics Edmonton - New York Islanders

Edmonton Oilers Team Overview
Edmonton have secured three wins in their last five games, though the early January performance of the Stanley Cup finalist hasn't been remarkable. They have only convincingly outplayed the modest Nashville and Chicago by more than two goals recently, and they just lost to the Predators in a back-to-back matchup (4-3 OT). Edmonton's offense, led by McDavid, remains exceptional, averaging 3.4 goals per game, with that number jumping to 3.85 when playing at home. However, defense continues to be the Achilles' heel for the Albertans, as they concede more than three goals both at home and on the road. The only player currently on their injury list is the experienced Adam Henrique. Notably, Zach Hyman has been impressive, scoring four goals in his last four games after missing the start of the season.
Match Results: Edmonton Oilers

New York Islanders Team Overview
The Islanders have secured the fifth spot in the Eastern Conference standings, with the "Islanders" having played one game less than their closest rivals. Six wins in their last ten games underscore the American team's stability. On average, the New Yorkers score three goals per game and concede just under three, indicating a balance between offense and defense. In early January, Barzal and his teammates faltered against Utah (2-7) and struggled this week against Winnipeg (4-5). In other instances, they've performed admirably, such as their dominant victory over New Jersey (9-0). Center Bo Horvat is expected to return to the lineup soon and bolster his team, although defenseman Romanov and forward Palmieri are sidelined for an extended period.
Match Results: New York Islanders
🏒 Projected Lineups
Islanders: Sorokin - Schaefer, Pulock - Lee, Barzal, Duclair
Edmonton: Jarry - Ekholm, Bouchard - Nugent-Hopkins, McDavid, Hyman
🥅 Goalies
Ilya Sorokin, back as the Islanders' last line of defense after an injury, performed well in two games before struggling against Winnipeg, conceding five goals to the Canadian side. Currently, Sorokin's goals-against average stands at 2.57 over 27 games.
Tristan Jarry also returned from an upper-body injury and has already played one game. In the back-to-back clash with Nashville, Tristan managed to save only 85% of the shots from the team in white and yellow. Since being traded from Pittsburgh, Jarry's goals-against average hasn't been stellar, standing at 3.28.
⭐ Editorial Prediction
The hosts favor an aggressive playing style with a focus on offense, while the visitors might leverage a balanced approach between defense and attack to control the game's tempo and create dangerous counter-attacking opportunities as needed. Considering the current form of both teams, we suggest betting on the Islanders with a +1.5 spread. The Islanders have maintained this spread in 4 of their last 5 head-to-head matchups against Edmonton. We believe the New Yorkers boast a more stable defensive line. Moreover, the return of center Bo Horvat could coincide with this game against the Oilers.