Columbus vs Pittsburgh Prediction 9 October 2026
🔊 Pittsburgh opened the regular season with two wins in their first three games but head to Columbus coming off a loss to Washington. The Blue Jackets have had a less convincing start, and their most recent home outing ended in defeat to Utah. These teams also share some recent history: on September 24, Columbus routed the Penguins at Nationwide Arena in a preseason clash. Now, these Metropolitan Division rivals face off with points on the line.
60 minutes were not enough
📊 In last season’s regular campaign, none of the four meetings between these rivals ended with a margin greater than one goal. Pittsburgh came out on top twice, while Columbus responded with two wins of their own-5-4 in regulation and 4-3 in a shootout. The head-to-head record finished level at 2-2. Notably, all four games saw the teams combine for at least seven goals.
Head-to-head statistics Columbus - Pittsburgh
Red cards spoiled the home fixture.
Columbus opened the season with a win over Buffalo, but dropped their home opener at Nationwide Arena to Utah, falling 1-4. The Blue Jackets once again conceded first, with Kent Johnson netting their only goal early in the second period. Jet Greaves turned aside 27 shots, but the opposition capitalized on the power play three times. After the game, Zach Werenski pointed directly to penalties as a key factor in the defeat, while Rick Bowness voiced his frustration over turnovers and the team's transition from offense to defense.
Heading into the matchup with Pittsburgh, Columbus are dealing with injury concerns on the blue line. Ivan Provorov is sidelined with a lower-body injury, Dante Fabbro is out with an upper-body issue, and Isac Lundeström will also miss the game. Damon Severson’s status remained questionable. Meanwhile, Mikael Pyyhtia has been activated off injured reserve, cleared waivers, and assigned to the Cleveland Monsters. Last season, he made five appearances for the Blue Jackets, recording one point, and tallied 49 points in 59 games in the AHL.
Match Results: Columbus Blue Jackets
The comeback started too late.
After opening the season with two straight wins, Pittsburgh suffered their first defeat with Arturs Silovs in net, as Washington claimed a 5-3 victory. The Penguins conceded on the very first shift, and by the midway point of the second period, they found themselves trailing 1-4. Bryan Rust marked his return from injury by scoring in his season debut, while Tommy Novak and Nick Robertson also found the net. Pittsburgh managed to pull within one goal, but couldn’t complete the comeback.
The main issue for Pittsburgh proved to be their puck management. Several of Washington’s goals came directly off Penguins’ turnovers, and Dan Muse singled out the lack of support for the puck carrier and the excessive gaps between players as key concerns after the game. During the contest, the coach continued to shuffle his lines: Rust moved up alongside Sidney Crosby and Rickard Rakell, while a productive attack featuring Novak’s goal was orchestrated by Egor Chinakhov and Evgeni Malkin. Heading into their trip to Columbus, Pittsburgh’s injury list still includes Andrei Kuzmenko, Justin Brazeau, and Ryan Graves.
Match Results: Pittsburgh Penguins
Prediction for the 1st period
Head-to-head clashes between Columbus and Pittsburgh consistently get off to a lively start. In each of their last five meetings, both sides have combined for at least two goals in the opening period. Backing over 1.5 goals in the first period looks like a solid pick here.
Total Prediction
Pittsburgh consistently reach the three-goal mark when they face Columbus. The Penguins have managed this in ten of their last eleven head-to-head clashes. Our pick: Pittsburgh team total over 2.5 goals.
Match Outcome Prediction
Despite last season’s results, Columbus maintain a strong head-to-head trend over a longer stretch: the Blue Jackets have avoided defeat in regulation in seven of their last eight meetings with Pittsburgh. The smart play here is Columbus Double Chance (1X) in regulation.
⭐️ Editor’s Prediction
This matchup has consistently delivered high-scoring hockey: the over 5.5 goals line has hit in nine of their last ten head-to-head clashes. There’s little reason to expect a different story this season. Three of Pittsburgh’s first four games have seen at least six goals, while Columbus’ home opener against Buffalo produced a wild nine-goal shootout in regulation. Last season, these teams never combined for fewer than seven goals in any of their four meetings. That’s why my pick here is over 5.5 goals.
Will this prediction come true?
No comments
Other predictions
