Columbus vs Buffalo Prediction 1 October 2026
🔊 Last season finally ended differently for Buffalo-the Sabres’ campaign stretched beyond April as they snapped a 15-year playoff drought. They knocked off Boston in the opening round, only falling to Montreal in a dramatic Game 7. Columbus, meanwhile, found themselves on the outside looking in yet again, missing the Stanley Cup Playoffs for the sixth consecutive year. The Blue Jackets stumbled badly down the stretch, losing nine of their final 11 games. Now, these teams square off early in the new campaign, having already faced each other in a preseason tune-up back in September.
Buffalo responded even before the game got underway
📊 Last regular season, these teams faced off three times, with Columbus coming out on top in two of those meetings. However, Buffalo dominated the most recent clash, cruising to a 5-0 victory. The average total across those three games was 5.6 goals. They also met once more in September: after a level first period, the Sabres netted three unanswered goals in the second.
Head-to-head statistics Columbus - Buffalo

There’s no safety margin left this spring.
Columbus wrapped up last season with a 40-30-12 record, but that wasn’t enough to secure a playoff spot. The second half of the campaign was particularly inconsistent. After Rick Bowness took over, the team surged to 19 wins in their first 27 games, losing just four in regulation. However, they managed only two victories in their final 11 outings. Special teams remained a weak point: their power play ranked 22nd in the league at 18.9%, while the penalty kill finished 28th with a 76% success rate.
The roster underwent significant changes over the summer. Boone Jenner and Mason Marchment both departed, but Valeri Nichushkin arrived from Colorado after posting 49 points (17 goals, 32 assists) in 72 games last season. Zach Werenski stayed with the club. In goal, Jet Greaves is likely to shoulder the main workload again, as Elvis Merzlikins is sidelined indefinitely following shoulder surgery.
Match Results: Columbus Blue Jackets

One surge changed the entire season.
Buffalo wrapped up the first 29 games of last season with an 11-14-4 record, sitting at the bottom of the Eastern Conference standings. Then came a stunning ten-game winning streak, and the Sabres finished the remainder of the campaign with an impressive 39-9-5 run. That surge vaulted the team to the top of the Atlantic Division, secured their first playoff appearance in 15 years, and saw them advance past the opening round.
Their main weapon was offense-averaging 3.45 goals per game, good for fifth in the NHL. Scoring depth extended well beyond the top line: five players hit the 20-goal mark, thirteen reached double digits, and ten skaters notched at least 40 points. Over the summer, Buffalo parted ways with Alex Tuch and Bowen Byram. As the new season approaches, there are roster concerns: Mattias Samuelsson has landed on injured reserve, while the status of Luukkonen and Lyon remains uncertain after preseason injuries.
Match Results: Buffalo Sabres
⚡️ Key Players
Zach Werenski led Columbus in scoring last season, racking up 81 points (22 goals, 59 assists) over 75 games from the blue line. Kirill Marchenko wrapped up the campaign with 67 points (27 goals, 40 assists) in 76 appearances, while Adam Fantilli posted 59 points (24 goals, 35 assists) across all 82 games.
For Buffalo, Tage Thompson tallied 81 points (40 goals, 41 assists) in 81 games, standing out as the only player among the trio mentioned to hit the 40-goal mark. Rasmus Dahlin contributed 74 points (19 goals, 55 assists) over 77 contests, and Josh Doan played the full 82-game slate, notching 52 points (25 goals, 27 assists).
🥅 Goaltenders
Jet Greaves featured in 55 games for Columbus last season, earning 26 wins. He posted a .908 save percentage, a 2.60 goals-against average, and recorded two shutouts. Cam Talbot joins from Detroit, where he made 34 appearances with 12 wins, an .883 save percentage, and a 3.19 GAA.
Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen picked up 22 wins in 35 starts for Buffalo, boasting a .910 save percentage and a 2.52 GAA. Alex Lyon suited up for 36 games, securing 20 victories and three shutouts with a .907 save percentage and a 2.77 GAA. Both goalies picked up injuries late in the preseason, so their status for the opener remains uncertain.
⭐️ Editor’s Prediction
The recent head-to-head clashes between these two sides have all followed a clear trend. If we look at last year’s two preseason meetings, their three regular season games, and the matchup in September, that’s six straight contests where the total has stayed under 6.5 goals. Preseason form points in the same direction: neither Columbus nor Buffalo saw more than six goals scored in any of their four exhibition games. My pick is under 6.5 goals.