Blue Jays vs Reds Prediction 25 September 2026
📡 With both teams out of realistic contention for October, the final stretch of the regular season shapes up as a matchup free from playoff pressure. Cincinnati arrive on the back of a thrilling 7-6 win over Atlanta, launching three homers in the process. Toronto return home after a tough road series in Baltimore. The starting matchup between Nick Lodolo and Jose Soriano sets the stage for a potentially high-scoring affair on both sides.
Toronto and Cincinnati have split their last ten head-to-head meetings, with neither side able to establish consistent dominance.
📊 The last ten head-to-head meetings are split evenly at 5-5. These teams don’t face each other often, so historical stats matter less than current serving form. There’s no consistent home side in this matchup, and today’s opening clash carries much more weight than any past record.
Head-to-head statistics Blue Jays - Reds

The Blue Jays return home to face Lodolo, who comes in with a WHIP close to 1.5.
The Blue Jays wrapped up their wild card chase on a tough note, dropping the series in Baltimore and officially bowing out of contention. Still, at home, this lineup remains capable of putting up runs in a hurry-especially against a pitcher who struggles with command. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. continues to anchor the order, and with no more postseason pressure, Toronto are free to swing for power and play with looseness in their final series of the season.
Match Results: Toronto Blue Jays

The Reds arrive on the back of a seven-run performance and three home runs in the series finale against Atlanta.
The Reds head to Canada coming off one of their most explosive offensive performances of the week. On Thursday, they edged Atlanta 7-6, with Elly De La Cruz launching his 30th home run of the season. Cincinnati wrapped up the series with three long balls, proving that even after falling out of playoff contention, their lineup still packs plenty of power. That’s a significant signal for the total ahead of their matchup with Soriano.
Match Results: Cincinnati Reds
⚾ Starting Pitchers
Nick Lodolo takes the mound for the visitors, carrying a 3-6 record with a 5.04 ERA and a 1.47 WHIP. Over his four September starts, he has surrendered 12 earned runs across 24.2 innings. In each of those outings, Lodolo has allowed at least two runs, and on three occasions he’s given up three or more. His elevated WHIP consistently gives opponents multiple scoring opportunities within the same inning.
José Soriano, meanwhile, has conceded 14 earned runs over his last 23 innings across four starts. His two most recent outings have been particularly rough-he gave up four runs to Detroit and five earned against Texas. While his season ERA hovers around 3.7, Soriano’s September form has dipped well below his year-long average.
⭐ Editor’s Prediction
Both halves of this pitching matchup offer plenty of opportunities for offense. Lodolo is carrying an ERA north of 5.00 with a 1.47 WHIP this season, while Soriano has surrendered nine earned runs over his last two starts. Cincinnati are coming off a seven-run, three-homer performance in Atlanta, and Toronto get a favorable home matchup against a lefty who consistently allows baserunners. Clearing the 8.5 total doesn’t require both starters to collapse-just one big early inning could open the floodgates. The best play here looks to be the over 8.5 total runs.