Blue Jays vs Pirates Prediction 23 May 2026
📡 Toronto cruised to a 6-2 victory in the series opener, but tonight’s matchup promises a much tougher challenge for their offense. Pittsburgh send Paul Skenes to the mound, boasting a 2.62 ERA and a 0.71 WHIP, while the hosts counter with Patrick Corbin, who will be looking to keep things steady early on and avoid a quick collapse. The prediction for under 7.5 total runs is based primarily on Skenes’ impressive profile and the expectation that Toronto will face a significantly stiffer test after yesterday’s win.
Head-to-Head
📊 Toronto have taken seven of the last ten head-to-head meetings. Blue Jays’ wins: (6-2, 7-3, 5-4, 5-3, 10-1, 8-2, 4-0). Pirates’ victories: (2-1, 5-2, 8-1). In terms of totals, there have been five games over, four under, and one push. Yesterday’s matchup saw eight runs scored, but tonight’s pitching duel looks set for a lower-scoring affair with Skenes on the mound, as he rarely allows opponents free baserunners.
Head-to-head statistics Blue Jays - Pirates
Toronto Blue Jays Team Overview
Toronto are enjoying a strong run, riding a three-game winning streak that includes a commanding 6-2 victory in the opening matchup of the series against Pittsburgh. The Blue Jays capitalized on defensive mistakes, got key hits from the heart of their lineup, and closed out the game with little trouble. However, repeating that script against Skenes will be far more challenging. The hosts will need to earn their way on base without any freebies, which makes it much harder to sustain constant offensive pressure.
Match Results: Toronto Blue Jays
Pittsburgh Pirates Team Overview
Pittsburgh fell short yesterday not just because of their pitching, but also due to three defensive errors that allowed Toronto to put together a decisive inning. Offensively, the Pirates didn't look completely out of sorts, but they'll need to be more cautious against Corbin: avoiding easy outs and not letting the game turn into a chase. On the bright side for the under, Pittsburgh have Skenes on the mound, which means they can keep things tight and look to capitalize on one or two key scoring opportunities instead of opening up the game.
Match Results: Pittsburgh Pirates
⚾ Starting Pitchers
Patrick Corbin is slated to start for Toronto, carrying a 1-1 record, a 4.23 ERA, and a 1.49 WHIP. His profile poses the main risk for the under, as he tends to allow a lot of baserunners. However, against Pittsburgh, he doesn’t need to dominate-he just needs to avoid giving up a big early inning and keep the game within two or three runs through the middle frames. If Corbin can limit walks ahead of the heart of the Pirates’ order, the 7.5 total remains in play.
Paul Skenes gets the nod for Pittsburgh with a 6-3 record, a 2.62 ERA, and a 0.71 WHIP. He’s the primary reason to lean towards the under. Over his last five starts, Skenes boasts a 0.84 ERA, including two outings of eight shutout innings and consistently sharp command. Facing Toronto-a team that capitalized on defensive miscues yesterday-Skenes has the tools to significantly reduce easy scoring opportunities.
⭐ Editor’s Prediction
The under 7.5 total hinges on the fact that Skenes has the potential to single-handedly dictate the flow of this series. Toronto cruised to a 6-2 win yesterday, but much of their offensive pressure came off Pittsburgh’s defensive miscues. Today, the Blue Jays face one of the league’s most reliable starters in terms of WHIP, who’s also in top form. Corbin does add some unpredictability, but Pittsburgh don’t need to force the tempo if Skenes keeps the hosts quiet. The first three or four innings will likely set the tone: if Toronto don’t break out early, this game could settle into a low-scoring battle where every run is at a premium. Even a 4-2 or 3-2 scoreline would keep the under in play. In our view, under 7.5 runs is the way to go here.
No comments
Betting Tips: Toronto Blue Jays - Pittsburgh Pirates
in last 9 Toronto Blue Jays home games against Pittsburgh Pirates (MLB).in 8 of last 9 Toronto Blue Jays games against Pittsburgh Pirates (MLB).in 8 of last 9 Toronto Blue Jays games (MLB).in 7 of last 8 Toronto Blue Jays games against Pittsburgh Pirates (MLB).in last 6 Toronto Blue Jays home games (MLB).in last 7 Pittsburgh Pirates away games (MLB).in 6 of last 7 away games against Toronto Blue Jays (MLB).in last 6 Toronto Blue Jays home games against Pittsburgh Pirates (MLB)..svg)
Other predictions
